Suggested questions for the Article Critique submissions Answer the following questions and write not more than a two-page critique for each of the articles that you select
1. Is the title appropriate?
2. Is the article theoretical, empirical, or both? Theoretical/Empirical/Both/Practitioner oriented
3. Does the article include: introduction, literature review, methodology, results, discussion, conclusion, references?
4. Does the article introduce the problem or new concepts clearly? Clear/Unclear introduction
5. Does the article address problems of significant concern to sustainability and/or social responsibility?
6. List three important facts from the literature review that the author(s) use(s) to support the main idea(s) of their article. 1-, 2-, 3-, or lacks objective reasoning/uses biased or unreliable sources
7. Are there any propositions or hypotheses?
8. If yes, then are propositions or hypotheses logically derived from the theory or conceptual framework?
9. Was the sample size sufficient?
10. Did the author(s) draw correct conclusions from the study/sample/analysis of their research intentions/hypotheses?
11. Was the discussion supported by appropriate statistical analysis?
12. List any examples of bias or faulty reasoning that you found in the article.
13. What information or ideas discussed in this article are also considered in your textbook and/or presented in this class? 1-, 2-, 3-, or All-new information
14. Managerial implications of the findings?
15. Did the article make a significant contribution to sustainability and/or social responsibility literature/fields?
