Peer Review Guidelines
These guidelines elaborate on key points to be covered in each section of the presentation, and should provide the basis for the comments you include in your peer review.
1. Identify the threat or opportunity. Describe the quantitative dimensions of the opportunity, as well as the qualitative motivations as they resonate with the core values of your organization or others who might be evaluating your proposal.
a. Does the material presented quantify the threat or opportunity in an absolute sense, and also in the context of the business, sector, or region? Does the quantification convince the listener that this is a high priority threat to address or opportunity to take, relative to the many other threats that could be addressed?
b. Is this quantification based in a rigorous scientific or technical assessment ?
c. Is the threat or opportunity linked clearly to the mission of the organization that would undertake it, or to the bottom line of the business?
