1. Correctly and clearly describe what the text is about. This is a 3-4 sentence summary of the main questions, goals, methods, and conclusions of the text.
2. Succinctly and clearly discuss the single most interesting idea or concept introduced in the text, and explain why exactly it is so compelling. Why should we care about this question?
3. Thoroughly discuss what is missing from the text, or how it could be improved. In the first case, the student explains exactly why this missing piece is important and how it
